What are college essays, and how are they different from school essays?

By: Chris Jonas

College Admissions Coach

Prefer to listen to this post? Click below.

The distinctions beyond academic content between a college essay and a school essay:

A college essay, often referred to as a personal statement or admissions essay, is a unique and crucial component of a college application. It is a written document that allows applicants to introduce themselves, showcase their personality, and convey their individuality to college admissions committees. College essays serve as a way for admissions officers to gain deeper insights into the applicant beyond what can be discerned from grades, test scores, and other application materials. These essays are typically required as part of the application process for undergraduate programs at colleges and universities.

Here are some key differences between college essays and school essays:

Audience and Purpose:

School Essays: School essays are primarily written for teachers or instructors and are meant to demonstrate understanding of the subject matter, critical thinking skills, and the ability to communicate effectively. They often have a clear academic purpose, such as to answer a specific question or complete an assignment.

College Essays: College essays are written for college admissions committees. Their primary purpose is to provide a personal, unique, and often reflective insight into the applicant's character, values, experiences, and aspirations. These essays aim to help admissions officers understand who the applicant is as an individual and why they would be a valuable addition to the college community.

Content and Style:

School Essays: School essays typically follow a structured, formal style, often using academic language and adhering to specific formatting guidelines (e.g., MLA or APA). They focus on presenting a clear argument or analysis of a particular topic, and the content is usually related to the course material or the assignment prompt.

College Essays: College essays are more personal and narrative in nature. While they should still be well-structured and coherent, they allow for a more creative and individualized approach. These essays may touch on various topics, including personal experiences, challenges, accomplishments, and future goals. Creativity and authenticity are encouraged, making each essay unique.

Length and Prompts:

School Essays: School essays often have specific word counts or page limits the instructor sets. They typically respond to a particular question or prompt related to the course material.

College Essays: College essay prompts can vary widely from one institution to another and may or may not have strict word limits. Some colleges offer a choice of essay prompts, allowing applicants to select the one that resonates most with their personal experiences and stories. This flexibility allows applicants to share what they consider most important.

Review and Feedback:

School Essays: Teachers or instructors typically review and grade school essays. Students may receive feedback on their writing and have the opportunity to revise and improve their work.

College Essays: College essays are a critical part of the college application, and applicants often seek guidance and feedback from teachers, counselors, or writing coaches. Some colleges also offer resources for essay support. However, the essays should ultimately reflect the applicant's voice and experiences.

Tone and Voice:

School Essays: A formal and academic tone is generally expected in school essays. Students are often encouraged to maintain a neutral and objective voice, focusing on presenting evidence and arguments logically and coherently. The emphasis is on demonstrating knowledge and critical thinking rather than revealing personal experiences or emotions.

College Essays: College essays offer a unique opportunity for students to showcase their individuality, personality, and voice. While they should still be well-written and organized, they allow for a more personal and sometimes conversational tone. Admissions committees are interested in hearing the applicant's authentic voice and perspective, making storytelling and self-expression essential components.

Content Focus:

School Essays: School essays are typically centered around academic subjects and assignments. They often require research, citation of sources, and evidence-based arguments. The content is expected to be relevant to the course or studied topic.

College Essays: College essays have a broader scope and may touch on various aspects of the applicant's life, such as personal experiences, values, cultural background, and aspirations. These essays may explore topics that are not strictly academic but are meaningful to the applicant's personal growth and character.

Editing and Revising:

School Essays: School essays are generally subject to multiple drafts and revisions, with feedback provided by teachers or professors. Students are encouraged to improve their writing skills through the revision process.

College Essays: College essays also benefit from revision and editing, but the process may involve seeking feedback from multiple sources, including teachers, counselors, peers, and family members. It's common for students to revise their college essays several times to ensure they convey the desired message effectively.

Purpose of Assessment:

School Essays: In the context of school essays, assessment is primarily focused on evaluating students' comprehension of the subject matter, their ability to analyze and synthesize information, and their proficiency in academic writing.

College Essays: The primary purpose of college essays is to provide admissions committees with a deeper understanding of the applicant as an individual. While the quality of writing is essential, these essays are evaluated in the context of the applicant's overall profile, including grades, test scores, and extracurricular activities.

Impact on Decision-Making:

School Essays: The impact of school essays is typically limited to the course or assignment for which they are written. They contribute to a student's academic record but generally do not influence decisions beyond the classroom.

College Essays: College essays play a significant role in the college admissions process. They can be a decisive factor in whether an applicant is admitted to a college or university. Admissions committees use these essays to assess applicants' fit for the institution and their potential contributions to the campus community.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, while both school and college essays involve writing, their purposes, styles, content, and audiences differ significantly. College essays provide applicants with a platform to express their individuality, share personal stories, and connect with admissions committees personally. These essays are a vital component of the holistic admissions process, allowing colleges to admit students with strong academic records and individuals who will contribute positively to the campus community. Therefore, crafting a compelling college essay is crucial in the college application journey.

Discussion Question:

Join the conversation and participate with the 24/7 College Admissions community by answering the DQ in the comment section below:

In addition to academic content, college essays often embrace personal narratives and unique experiences. How do these distinctive elements impact the way college essays are written, and what challenges and opportunities do they present for students in crafting compelling personal statements?

Did you know the earlier you start the college application process, the easier it is? If you are ready to start thinking about the college application process, set up a free strategy call with one of our 24/7 College Admissions specialists and learn everything you need to create a successful college application plan for yourself or your teen.