The Four Pillars of a Writing a Winning College Essay

By: Chris Jonas

College Admissions Coach

Prefer to listen to this post? Click below.

Writing a Winning College Essay:

Introduction

The transition from high school to college is a defining moment in a student's life. With college applications come the daunting yet exciting task of writing a college admissions essay. The essay plays a pivotal role in giving admissions officers an insight into who you are beyond just test scores and GPA. So, how do you make your essay stand out? This comprehensive guide introduces you to the four key pillars of writing an impressive college essay: Authenticity, Vulnerability, Impactfulness, and Uniqueness, or the "So-What Rule."

If you're looking to further refine your essay and other aspects of your college application, consider 24/7 Teach's College Admissions Coaching services and our College Essay Writing Bootcamp. Want proof that our approach works? Read this blog post by one of our recent bootcamp graduates, who secured a full scholarship to an Ivy League school.

Authenticity

What is Authenticity, and Why Does it Matter?

One of the most common questions students ask is, "How do I write a good college admissions essay?" The answer starts with Authenticity. Authenticity means presenting your true self in your writing. Admissions officers read thousands of essays every year; they can easily spot a fake. Your essay is your chance to show who you are, not who you think colleges want you to be.

What Do Colleges Want to See in an Admissions Essay?

Authenticity is high on the list. College admissions officers look for essays that provide a clear and genuine picture of the applicant. They appreciate honesty and can often tell when a student is being insincere or exaggerating. Authentic essays come from self-reflection and an in-depth understanding of oneself, which is why it’s crucial to consider your life experiences, values, and passions before putting pen to paper.

How to Showcase Authenticity

Be Honest: Don't embellish your achievements or create a narrative that isn't true to who you are.
Share Your Values: Explain what matters to you and why.
Avoid Clichés: Colleges receive countless essays about “life-changing” volunteer trips and the “eye-opening” experience of leading a sports team to victory. Make sure your topic truly reflects your interests and experiences.

Vulnerability

The Power of Vulnerability

Being vulnerable in your essay means sharing aspects of yourself that you may not usually discuss openly. These could be challenges you've faced, mistakes you've made, or even weaknesses you've identified and are working on. Vulnerability provides a window into your ability to overcome challenges and grow from them.

How to Infuse Vulnerability in Your Essay

Discuss Challenges: Without dwelling on the negative, discuss the challenges you've faced and what you've learned from them.
Reflect on Growth: How did the experience change you? What did you learn?
Be Self-Aware: Demonstrating that you are reflective and self-aware shows maturity and the ability to adapt to new situations, a quality colleges value.

Impactfulness

What Does it Mean to be Impactful?

Being impactful means that your essay leaves a lasting impression on the reader. An impactful essay shows why you would be an asset to the college community and how you plan to contribute in the future.

How to Write an Impactful Essay

Be Specific: Provide concrete examples of your achievements and how you've made a positive impact.
Discuss Future Goals: Briefly outline your future ambitions and how you plan to achieve them, particularly how you intend to contribute to the college community and beyond.
Make it Relevant: Relate your essay back to why you would be a good fit for the particular college and its programs.

Uniqueness and the So-What Rule

Why Uniqueness Matters

In the sea of qualified candidates, your uniqueness is your biggest asset. This doesn’t mean you have to have a unique life story; instead, it means you have a unique perspective on common experiences.

How to Make Your Essay Unique

Find Your Angle: Think about how your viewpoint or experiences make you different.
Voice and Tone: Your writing style can be a tool for showcasing your uniqueness. Just ensure it remains appropriate for an academic essay.

The So-What Rule

This brings us to the “So-What Rule.” Your essay should make the reader stop and think, “So what? Why should I care about this?” If you’re writing about a common topic like “overcoming failure,” what is it about your experience that makes it worth reading?

Mastering the art of the college essay can seem like a daunting task, but by focusing on the four key pillars—Authenticity, Vulnerability, Impactfulness, and Uniqueness—you can craft a compelling narrative that stands out. Let's dive deeper.

Authenticity (Continued)

Actionable Tips for Authenticity

A. Self-Reflection Exercises: Before you begin writing, take some time to jot down moments in your life that have shaped who you are. This exercise can help you identify the real 'you' that you want to present in your essay.

B. Seek Feedback but Stay True: While it's useful to get feedback on your essay, ensure that the final version is still authentically 'you.'

Real-World Example of Authenticity

Imagine you're an aspiring environmental science major. Instead of writing a generic essay about your love for nature, focus on the specific moment you realized you wanted to dedicate yourself to environmental issues. Maybe it was when you started a recycling program at your school, or perhaps it was the influence of a particular book or person. The more personal and genuine your essay, the more it will stand out.

Vulnerability (Continued)

Actionable Tips for Vulnerability

A. The "Three Whys" Technique: For every challenge or failure you discuss, ask yourself 'why' three times to get to the root cause and your emotional response to it.

B. Balanced Perspective: Vulnerability does not mean weakness. Show how your vulnerabilities have led to strengths or growth.

Real-World Example of Vulnerability

Suppose you struggled in your freshman year academically but showed steady improvement over the years. Don't shy away from discussing this. Instead, you could write about how this struggle helped you develop resilience and better study habits.

Impactfulness (Continued)

Actionable Tips for Impactfulness

A. Use Data: If possible, include quantifiable impacts of your actions, like “Raised $5,000 for a local animal shelter” or “Tutored 15 students in underprivileged communities.”

B. Show, Don't Tell: Instead of saying you’re passionate about community service, provide examples of your volunteer work and describe how these experiences had a lasting impact on you and your community.

Real-World Example of Impactfulness

Maybe you have a passion for social justice and started a blog to raise awareness about various issues. Describe how this blog attracted thousands of readers and led to community action or changed perspectives.

Uniqueness and the So-What Rule (Continued)

Actionable Tips for Uniqueness

A. The 'So What?' Test: Once you've written your essay, read it and ask yourself, "So what?". If your essay doesn't answer this question, go back to the drawing board.

B. Unusual Hobbies or Skills: Sometimes, uniqueness can be highlighted through uncommon hobbies or skills you possess that could make you a more interesting addition to the college community.

Real-World Example of Uniqueness

Let's say you are an expert at beekeeping and have won several awards for honey production. That's an unusual and interesting skill that could make for a fascinating essay and contribute to your uniqueness.

Final Thoughts

Crafting a compelling college essay is a process that demands time, introspection, and multiple drafts. Keep the four pillars—Authenticity, Vulnerability, Impactfulness, and Uniqueness—in mind, and you'll be well on your way to writing an essay that is both meaningful and memorable.

If you’re still feeling a bit overwhelmed, don't hesitate to check out 24/7 Teach's expert College Admissions Coaching services and our College Essay Writing Bootcamp.

Remember, the journey of writing a college essay is also one of self-discovery. Enjoy the process and good luck!

Discussion Question:

Join the conversation and participate with the 24/7 College Admissions community by answering the DQ in the comment section below:

What personal experiences have you found most challenging to include in your college essay due to vulnerability or fear of judgment, and how did you overcome those challenges to create an impactful and authentic narrative?

Did you know the earlier you start the college application process, the easier it is? If you are ready to start thinking about the college application process, set up a free strategy call with one of our 24/7 College Admissions specialists and learn everything you need to create a successful college application plan for yourself or your teen.